Skip to content
Cyrrus Consulting Services
ES
Artificial intelligence

AI agents: what they are, when they pay off and what to decide before investing

A vendor offers you an AI agent that promises to resolve a whole process without intervention. Before approving the budget it helps to know what an agent really is, when it is worth it compared with simpler automation and which controls leadership should require.

AI agents: what they are, when they pay off and what to decide before investing

The proposal arrives with a promise: an agent that reads the emails, queries the ERP, decides and executes. The demo is flawless. What the demo does not show is what happens when the agent gets it wrong, how much it costs to maintain, or whether the process needed an agent in the first place.

This guide explains what an AI agent is, how it differs from a chatbot and from an automated workflow, when it makes sense, which risks the sources acknowledge and what leadership should decide before investing.

What is an AI agent?

IBM defines an AI agent as a system that autonomously performs tasks by designing workflows with the tools available to it. Its core is a large language model, which is why they are also called LLM agents. They can go beyond conversation: they make decisions, solve problems, interact with external systems and take actions.

According to IBM, what separates an agent from a non-agentic chatbot is that the chatbot has no tools, memory or reasoning: it pursues short-term goals and needs continuous input from the user. An agent breaks the task into steps, uses tools (databases, searches, programming interfaces) and corrects its plan as it observes results.

Anthropic, in its guide to building agents, makes a distinction that is useful for decision-makers: workflows are systems in which a model and tools are orchestrated through paths defined in code; agents are systems in which the model directs its own process and tool usage and keeps control over how it accomplishes the task.

How does an agent differ from a chatbot or an automated workflow?

The difference that matters for the business is who decides the path. The table summarizes what IBM and Anthropic say.

Chatbot, automated workflow and agent according to IBM and Anthropic
TypeWho decides the pathWhat the source says
Non-agentic chatbotThe user, at every exchangeNo tools, memory or reasoning; needs continuous user input (IBM)
WorkflowThe code, with steps defined in advanceModel and tools orchestrated through predefined paths; suited to well-defined tasks (Anthropic)
AgentThe model itself, during executionDirects its own process and tool usage; preferred when flexibility and model-driven decisions are needed at scale (Anthropic)

For the difference between an agent and robotic process automation (RPA), see the guide on what RPA is and when it makes sense versus artificial intelligence.

Does your process need an agent or something simpler?

We start from a diagnosis of the process and the company's architecture, and we only build custom when the right solution does not exist on the market.

  • Process diagnosis before choosing the technology
  • Solution integrated into the company's AI architecture
Explore AI agents and automation
Cyrrus consultant reviewing a process that is a candidate for automation with an executive

When does it make sense to use an agent, and when not?

Anthropic recommends finding the simplest solution possible and only increasing complexity when needed, and notes that this might mean not building agentic systems at all. For many applications, it says, optimizing a single model call with retrieval and examples is enough. Multi-step systems are justified when simpler solutions fall short.

Gartner reaches a similar conclusion from the market side. Its analyst Anushree Verma says that many use cases positioned as agentic today do not require an agentic implementation, and suggests using agents when decisions are needed, automation for routine workflows and assistants for simple retrieval. Gartner recommends pursuing agentic AI only where it delivers clear value or ROI.

In our view, three questions order the decision: if the path of the process can be written in advance, an automated workflow is usually enough; if the outcome cannot tolerate errors without review, the agent needs human approval at every critical step; and if nobody can explain the measurable benefit, it is not yet time to invest.

What risks and costs does an agent carry?

IBM lists four limitations. First, multi-agent dependencies: orchestration can malfunction, and agents built on the same model can share weaknesses. Second, infinite feedback loops, in which the agent calls the same tools again and again. Third, computational complexity: building them can be slow and expensive, and some tasks take several days. Fourth, data privacy, which gets complicated if the integration is poorly managed and there is no human oversight.

Anthropic adds that agentic systems often trade latency and cost for better task performance, and that their autonomous nature means higher costs and the potential for compounding errors. It also asks for some level of trust in the agent's decisions.

At market level, Gartner predicts that over 40% of agentic AI projects will be canceled by the end of 2027, due to escalating costs, unclear business value or inadequate risk controls. It is a prediction, not a measurement, and should be read that way. The same release cites a January 2025 poll of 3,412 webinar attendees: 19% said they had made significant investments in agentic AI, 42% conservative investments, 8% none, and the rest were waiting or unsure.

The question is not whether the agent works in the demo, but who answers when it fails in production.

Which controls should leadership require?

IBM recommends four practices to limit risk: an activity log showing what the agent did; the ability for a person to interrupt it gracefully; unique agent identifiers, for traceability and accountability; and human supervision with prior approval for high-impact actions, such as mass emails or financial trades.

Anthropic suggests including stopping conditions, such as a maximum number of iterations, and running extensive tests in sandboxed environments with appropriate guardrails. For coding agents, automated tests help, but human review remains necessary.

In our view, these controls are company rules before they are product features. NIST publishes a voluntary AI risk management framework (version 1.0, January 2023) and a generative AI profile (July 2024) that serve as references. To turn them into rules, roles and owners, see the guide on AI governance and reference frameworks.

An agent in production needs an owner

The same diagnosis defines who answers for each agent, which actions need human approval and how its activity is logged.

  • A defined owner for each agent
  • Critical actions with human approval
Talk to our team
Leadership team defining owners and limits for an AI agent

How do you avoid being sold old automation as an agent?

Gartner warns about "agent washing": vendors rebranding existing products, such as assistants, RPA or chatbots, without substantial agentic capabilities. By its estimate, only about 130 of the thousands of agentic AI vendors are real. It is a Gartner estimate, not a figure third parties can verify.

In our view, before comparing prices it helps to ask the vendor, in writing, to show on one of your processes: what the agent decides by itself and what the code decides; which tools it can use and with what permissions; what it logs and how it is interrupted; what happens when it gets it wrong; and how much it costs to run each month, not just to build.

What should leadership decide before investing?

The decision is not a technology one. There are four management decisions: the process and the business outcome to improve, with a before-and-after measure; whether an automated workflow is enough or an agent is justified; which actions the agent may execute on its own and which require human approval; and who owns the agent once it is in operation.

If those four decisions have no answer, what is called for is not buying an agent but organizing the process and the architecture it will rest on.

How we can help

At Cyrrus we start from the company's diagnosis and architecture, and only when the right solution does not exist on the market do we build it custom, integrated into that architecture rather than as a loose development. That is the approach of our AI agents and automation service.

If what is missing is the strategy that decides which processes to invest in first, we start with AI strategy; and if agents are already running without clear rules, with AI governance.

To go deeper: how to build the roadmap of an AI strategy and what to demand from an AI consulting firm before hiring it.

Jackson Bohorquez, CEO of Cyrrus Consulting Services
Jackson Bohorquez
CEO & Founder, Cyrrus Consulting Services

30 years in strategy and IT: Oracle consultant, IT leader at PepsiCo Latin America, Covidien and Coremar, and founder of Cyrrus in 2017. MBA, Universidad del Norte.

About the author
Published · November 18, 2026
Related service
Automation & AI Agents

Ready to connect the decision to the execution?

Tell us your organization's challenge. We'll set up a conversation with the right team and tell you straight whether we can help.

Not sure where to start? Request a free diagnostic session